| UFC Fight Night: Holloway vs. Allen | Zak Cummings | 1091 →1111(+20) | Ed Herman | 1041 →1022(-19) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 265: Lewis vs. Gane | Alonzo Menifield | 1024 →1047(+23) | Ed Herman | 1064 →1041(-23) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Waterson vs. Hill | Ed Herman | 1043 →1064(+21) | Mike Rodriguez | 1003 →983(-20) | Light Heavyweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Zabit vs. Kattar | Ed Herman | 1026 →1043(+17) | Khadis Ibragimov | 977 →959(-18) | Light Heavyweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Dos Anjos vs. Lee | Ed Herman | 1003 →1026(+23) | Patrick Cummins | 998 →975(-23) | Light Heavyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Oezdemir vs. Smith | Gian Villante | 996 →1017(+21) | Ed Herman | 1025 →1003(-22) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | S-DEC |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Redemption Finale | CB Dollaway | 1014 →1036(+22) | Ed Herman | 1047 →1025(-22) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC 201: Lawler vs. Woodley | Nikita Krylov | 1070 →1093(+23) | Ed Herman | 1070 →1047(-23) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Dillashaw vs Cruz | Ed Herman | 1049 →1070(+21) | Tim Boetsch | 1022 →1001(-21) | Light Heavyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 183: Silva vs Diaz | Derek Brunson | 1039 →1064(+25) | Ed Herman | 1074 →1049(-25) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Brown vs Silva | Ed Herman | 1055 →1074(+19) | Rafael Natal | 1034 →1015(-19) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 167: St-Pierre vs Hendricks | Thales Leites | 1064 →1085(+21) | Ed Herman | 1076 →1055(-21) | Middleweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC on FOX: Johnson vs Moraga | Ed Herman | 1059 →1076(+17) | Trevor Smith | 1000 →983(-17) | Middleweight | Win | S-DEC |
| UFC 150: Henderson vs Edgar II | Jake Shields | 1016 →1016 | Ed Herman | 1059 →1059 | Middleweight | nc
nc | Overturned |
| UFC 143: Diaz vs Condit | Ed Herman | 1037 →1059(+22) | Clifford Starks | 1020 →998(-22) | Middleweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC Live: Hardy vs Lytle | Ed Herman | 1011 →1037(+26) | Kyle Noke | 1067 →1041(-26) | Middleweight | Win | SUB |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Team Lesnar vs Team dos Santos Finale | Ed Herman | 984 →1011(+27) | Tim Credeur | 1048 →1020(-28) | Middleweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 102: Couture vs Nogueira | Aaron Simpson | 1023 →1044(+21) | Ed Herman | 1005 →984(-21) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 97: Redemption | Ed Herman | 982 →1005(+23) | David Loiseau | 1038 →1015(-23) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Diaz vs Neer | Alan Belcher | 1005 →1025(+20) | Ed Herman | 1002 →982(-20) | Middleweight | Loss | S-DEC |
| UFC 83: Serra vs St-Pierre 2 | Demian Maia | 1021 →1044(+23) | Ed Herman | 1025 →1002(-23) | Middleweight | Loss | SUB |
| UFC 78: Validation | Ed Herman | 1005 →1025(+20) | Joe Doerksen | 967 →946(-21) | Middleweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 72: Victory | Ed Herman | 982 →1005(+23) | Scott Smith | 977 →955(-22) | Middleweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Evans vs Salmon | Ed Herman | 958 →982(+24) | Chris Price | 978 →954(-24) | Middleweight | Win | SUB |
| Ortiz vs Shamrock 3: The Final Chapter | Jason MacDonald | 1000 →1021(+21) | Ed Herman | 980 →958(-22) | Middleweight | Loss | SUB |
The Ultimate Fighter: Team Ortiz vs. Team Shamrock Finale | Kendall Grove | 1000 →1020(+20) | Ed Herman | 1000 →980(-20) | Middleweight | Loss | U-DEC |
